EXTRANET NEWS * Week of 3 November 2003
Editors: Joel Orr and N'omi Orr
http://www.extranetnews.com

FLASH! Sign up for the EXTRANET NEWS teleseminar:
"How to Select and Implement an Extranet."
Two hours, $39.
Go to www.extranetnews.com for detai
ls.

1. A DESIGN FIRM CONSIDERS EXTRANETS
2. THE LIST
3.
TIDBITS
4.
QUOTE OF THE WEEK

 

1. A DESIGN FIRM CONSIDERS EXTRANETS

Joel interviewed Jill Rothenberg, AIA, principal and CIO of ADD Inc (www.addinc.com).

"Bricsnet ProjectCenter (www.bricsnet.com) is one of my favorites, because of its ease of use and flexibility. They also have good customer service and tech support," said Rothenberg when I asked her what extranets she recommends to owners and others.

The architect, she pointed out, is not always able to pick an extranet to use. "Sometimes the owner or the builder has made a selection, and we have to go with theirs."

What's the most important quality of an extranet, beyond its having the basic features needed for the project? "Ease of learning, ease of use; a friendly and convenient user interface. People just can't face yet one more technology change," she said.

Are there predictors for success? "Sure. The owner must be using it, and expecting everyone to use it. And key project people must be definite and disciplined in their use of the extranet. And of course, the system must be reliable."

What are some important features to look for in an extranet? "We, as architects, have needs that overlap with but are different from those of builders. We care about document sharing, flexible workflow, lots of choices in security designations--who can look at things, who can change them, by name and by role. We want easy uploading and downloading. RFI and submittal workflow and management--which is where construction-oriented systems excel--are important to us, too."

"By the way," commented Rothenberg, "per-seat charges are counter-productive, because they make cost-conscious project managers reluctant to get enough seats to supply all who really need them. Bricsnet charges by the project."

"Also, while I emphasize the need for ease of learning, training is critical. Everyone must know how to use the system," she added. "But it shouldn't take more than a couple of hours to learn."

"We are beginning to see a renewed interest in extranets on the part of our clients. It's taking a long time for this technology to get the attention and use it deserves," said Rothenberg.

Our take: The AEC world is excruciatingly slow to adopt technology. Architects, like ADD Inc, are happy to employ extranets, with their improved communication and control over the project. But architects, as Ms. Rothenberg indicates, have little leverage among project participants; they cannot require other players to use extranets. Ultimately, owners determine whether or not extranets will be employed to full advantage.


2. THE LIST

 

Total companies: 262 (see who's on The List at http://www.extranetnews.com/).  

 

 

3. TIDBITS 

·HOW TO SELECT AND IMPLEMENT AN EXTRANET - EXTRANET NEWS presents a two-hour teleseminar that can save you weeks and months--and lots of dollars! Hear users' comments. Q&A with users and Dr. Joel Orr, who is the lead presenter. We're giving it--live--on three dates: 11 November; 19 November; and 24 November, each at 1 pm EST.
Cost to attend: $39.
Go to www.extranetnews.com for info and registration.

·Basex Collaborative Business Environments Conference
2 December; The Penn Club;
New York, New York. www.strategicthinkers.com/strategic/dec03agenda.nsf/pages/home

· Conference Board of Canada Strategic Project Management Conference - 3-4 December, 2003; Hilton Toronto; 145 Richmond Street, West Toronto, ON Canada M5H 2L2. www.conferenceboard.ca/conf/dec03/project_mgmt/overview.htm

·PROJECT EXTRANETS IV: SUCCESSFUL COLLABORATIVE WORKING; MAXIMISING EXTRANETS FOR OPTIMUM RESULTS, organized by Ross Sturley and Construction News, London, England, 3 December 2003, at the IEE Savoy Place. The one I attended a couple of years ago was outstanding.
See http://www.projectextranets.co.uk/ for information.

·Knowledge Management for Government
15-16 December, Hyatt Regency Crystal City, Arlington, VA. http://www.federalevents.com/km/overview.shtml

·COFES2004: The Congress on the Future of Engineering Software
April 1-4, 2004, in Scottsdale, AZ. Mark your calendar!. Come meet very smart people and talk about the future of engineering technology!
http://www.cofes.com

 

4.QUOTE OF THE WEEK

"Experience teaches us to be most on our guard to protect liberty when the government's purpose is beneficent. Men born to freedom are naturally alert to repel invasion of their liberty by evil-minded rulers. The greatest dangers to liberty lurk in insidious encroachment by men of zeal, well-meaning but without understanding."

 --Supreme Court Justice Brandeis

‡‡‡‡‡‡‡‡‡

 

Entire newsletter Copyright © 2003 Cyon Research Corporation

To subscribe, please go to http://www.extranetnews.com. To unsubscribe, please reply with "remove" in the subject line. I'm interested in knowing why you'd want to unsubscribe; but it's not essential.